Bayesian Theory of Mind: Modeling Joint Belief-Desire Attribution
نویسندگان
چکیده
We present a computational framework for understanding Theory of Mind (ToM): the human capacity for reasoning about agents’ mental states such as beliefs and desires. Our Bayesian model of ToM (or BToM) expresses the predictive model of beliefand desire-dependent action at the heart of ToM as a partially observable Markov decision process (POMDP), and reconstructs an agent’s joint belief state and reward function using Bayesian inference, conditioned on observations of the agent’s behavior in some environmental context. We test BToM by showing participants sequences of agents moving in simple spatial scenarios and asking for joint inferences about the agents’ desires and beliefs about unobserved aspects of the environment. BToM performs substantially better than two simpler variants: one in which desires are inferred without reference to an agent’s beliefs, and another in which beliefs are inferred without reference to the agent’s dynamic observations in the environment.
منابع مشابه
Joint inferences of belief and desire from facial expressions
Theory of mind research has looked at how learners infer an agent’s unobservable mental states from observable actions. However, such research has tended to neglect another observable source of data: the agent’s reactions to events. In particular, the agent’s facial reactions might provide important information about her mental states that are otherwise ambiguous given her actions. Here we pres...
متن کاملModeling Human Plan Recognition using Bayesian Theory of Mind
The human brain is the most powerful plan recognition system we know. Central to the brain’s remarkable plan recognition capacity is a theory of mind (ToM): our intuitive conception of other agents’ mental states – chiefly, beliefs and desires – and how they cause behavior. We present a Bayesian framework for ToM-based plan recognition, expressing generative models of beliefand desire-dependent...
متن کاملCore mechanisms in "theory of mind".
Our ability to understand the thoughts and feelings of other people does not initially develop as a theory but as a mechanism. The "theory of mind" mechanism (ToMM) is part of the core architecture of the human brain, and is specialized for learning about mental states. Impaired development of this mechanism can have drastic effects on social learning, seen most strikingly in the autistic spect...
متن کاملThe Development of Joint Belief-Desire Inferences
Human beings infer complex mental states given very little information—a facial expression, a sarcastic tone, or even a simple behavior. Previous work suggests that adults make joint belief and desire inferences based on an actor’s path, and that these inferences are well-explained by a Bayesian framework (Baker, Saxe, & Tenenbaum, 2011). We investigate the development of this ability by assess...
متن کاملPartial belief and flat-out belief
There is a duality in our everyday view of belief. On the one hand, we sometimes speak of credence as a matter of degree. We talk of having some level of confidence in a claim (that a certain course of action is safe, for example, or that a desired event will occur) and explain our actions by reference to these degrees of confidence – tacitly appealing, it seems, to a probabilistic calculus suc...
متن کامل